You don't expect fantastic food at a brewery restaurant, but you should anticipate a good beer selection. I prefer wine, but I enjoy beer as well, and come on, what should one drink in this setting? I latched onto one option on the beverage menu: a 4-glass sampler of 4-oz. glasses. I didn't know which four beers to choosethe brewery makes about a dozen, and my beer knowledge is practically nonexistentso I told the server what I like (not too hoppy) and asked her to choose for me. Melissa chose a glass of Scrimshaw, which she figured would complement the Scrimshaw-based batter on the fish and chips.
I tasted them as I would wine: beer has its own complexities, its own rewards for those who take the time to think about the taste. I started with the beer that seemed the lightest: the Acme California Pale Ale. A co-worker tells me that North Coast Brewing Company bought Acme Brewery at some point in the past. My tasting notes mention a nose of lemon, with a taste that was dominated by hops but also had baking spice and vanilla components. I found it pleasant but not too exciting.
My second beer was the Pranqster, and I was immediately grabbed by the nose of vanilla and waxy flowers and banana. I loved the creamy mouth feel, like some sort of fizzy cream. The finish suggested bubble gum, and my overall impression says "smooth and silky". This is a beer I will seek out and buy again. In retrospect, my rapture makes sense. The only beer I claim to have any knowledge about is Belgian beer (which means I can chat happily with beer snobs about Saison Dupont and Westvletern), and the brewery considers this a "Belgian-style" beer.
The Acme California Brown Ale offered wheat and oatmeal on the nose, and felt smooth in the mouth, leaving a hoppy finish after I swallowed. I liked it, but it didn't turn my heart from the beer I drank just moments before.
The final beer in my sample was the Old No. 38 Stout. Melissa watched with a twinkle in her eye as I tasted this one. Definite cocoa on the nose, but that became coffee with a bitter finish as I drank the smooth liquid. I don't like coffee. I don't like coffee flavoring. And, it turns out, I don't like things that taste like coffee even when they're not. I couldn't get past that flavor in the beer to give an overall impression. Melissa finished my glass. I'm sure, as a stout, it's quite good. But I'll be steering clear of this one.
I'd love to sample all this brewery's beers. They were rich and complex, even when I didn't like them. And I'll eagerly keep an eye out for Pranqster in the future. My co-worker (who knows a lot about beer), says he and his wife like the brewery's Blue Star as a crisp summer drink ("the kind of beer you can put a lemon wedge in and enjoy on a hot day"), and he also recommends the Old Rasputin, "a porter but with a bright fruit finish."